This is definitely my go to place not only for pizza but for the best pasta in town. I have tried them all, and I cannot pick only one as my favorite. They make their dishes fresh and to order, their portions are more than enough, and their prices are the best in town. You cannot go wrong with I love New York pizza.

T. Ricks

Great place for a slice or a whole pie. They also sell take and bake pizzas. The food is amazing! Best pizza in Gainesville.

T. O’Steen

I have been impressed with the customer service every single time I have been here! And the food hasn’t disappointed me yet! I love their lunch specials. Highly recommend.

J. Hood

I ordered the Large deluxe and it was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! Delicious!

D. Kirchman

Fantastic slices and super friendly staff at lunch time.

L. Davis

An absolute must try when in Gainesville. Just amazing!

L. Leffingwell

photos by Adrienne Fletcher

I Love New York Pizza · We toss them, they’re awesome
2645 SW 91st St | Haile Market Square

 Find ’em at | facebook